← All posts

How to negotiate stock options and equity in a job offer

Key takeaways

Yes, you should negotiate your stock option grant, and equity can have room in it even when base salary doesn't. Before you counter, get four numbers from the company: the 409A valuation, your fully diluted ownership, the latest preferred price, and the vesting schedule. Value public-company RSUs as shares times price, spread over the vesting years. Then ask for more shares, a shorter cliff, acceleration on acquisition, or a refresh policy in writing. In Fidelity's 2022 Career Assessment Study, 87% of the young professionals who negotiated their current job offer got at least some of what they asked for.

The equity chapter of the video starts where this player picks up, scripts on screen. The full transcript is on the salary negotiation tools post.

Should you negotiate your stock option grant?

Yes. In Fidelity's 2022 Career Assessment Study, 58% of young professionals accepted their current job offer without negotiating, so they never tested what the offer could have been. Equity is a good place to push because it doesn't come out of the company's cash this quarter, so a recruiter with no room on base may still have room on shares.

Tie the ask to the whole package and a market comparison you can show, ask for one or two specific changes rather than a list, and make clear you want to say yes. "I'm excited about this, and the equity is the one piece I'd like to close the gap on" is a sentence a hiring manager can take back to the comp team.

If you're worried the offer will be pulled, Four-Leaf's post on what hiring managers actually do when you negotiate covers the research on that risk, and by employers' own accounts rescission is rare.

What are RSUs, ISOs and NSOs?

RSUs (restricted stock units) are a promise of shares on a schedule. You pay nothing for them. When they vest at a public company, you own shares you can sell that day. They're taxed as ordinary income when they vest, so the tax bill arrives whether you sell or not.

ISOs (incentive stock options) are the right to buy shares at a locked-in strike price. They're a common startup grant. An option is worth the gap between what a share sells for and your strike price, so it's worth nothing unless the share price eventually clears the strike. If you hold ISO shares past the later of one year after exercise and two years after the grant, IRS Publication 525 treats the gain as a capital gain rather than ordinary income.

NSOs (non-qualified stock options) work the same way mechanically, but the spread at exercise is taxed as ordinary income. They're common for contractors, advisors and some later-stage employees.

The distinction that matters most is liquidity. Public-company RSUs have a price you can look up and sell into. Private-company options have a paper value set by the last appraisal or funding round, and you can't turn them into cash until an IPO, an acquisition or a company-run tender offer, which may never come.

How do you evaluate stock options in a job offer?

For public-company RSUs, multiply the number of units by the current share price and divide by the vesting years. That's your annual equity figure. Look at the last few years of the stock chart before you treat it as fixed.

For startup options, the grant letter usually shows only a share count, and a share count on its own tells you nothing. Ask four questions.

What's the current 409A valuation, and when was it done? The 409A is the independent appraisal that sets your strike price.

What percentage of the company do my options represent, fully diluted? Divide your options by the total fully diluted share count. A grant that sounds large can be a tiny fraction of a company with a large share count, and the fraction is what you own.

What did investors pay per share in the latest round? Compare the preferred price with your strike. A wide gap is paper upside, provided the company keeps growing into it.

How much runway is there, and what's the path to liquidity? A pre-revenue company with a year of cash is a different bet from a profitable one preparing to go public.

A company that won't answer these is asking you to price a major part of your pay blind. That's worth saying out loud, politely, before you sign.

How do vesting schedules and cliffs work?

The default is four years with a one-year cliff. Carta's vesting guide, published July 29, says the standard at venture-backed companies remains a four-year time-based grant, and that at least 95% of cliffs are set at the one-year mark.

The cliff means nothing vests in year one. On your first anniversary, a quarter of the grant vests at once, and the rest typically vests monthly over the next three years. Leave at month eleven and you leave with nothing.

Not every company vests evenly. Brighton Jones, a wealth advisory firm that works with Amazon employees, wrote in 2022 that Amazon RSUs vest 5% in year one, 15% in year two and 40% in each of years three and four. A back-loaded grant is worth much less to you if you might leave after two years, so always ask for the year-by-year schedule along with the total.

How do you negotiate equity in a startup offer?

Start with total compensation. Add base, bonus and your annual equity value, then compare the total with market data from Levels.fyi, Glassdoor or Blind for the same level. If it falls short, you have a reason grounded in numbers.

"Based on my research, total compensation for this level at comparable companies runs from $X to $Y. The base is strong, but the equity puts the package below that range. Could we look at increasing the option grant to close the gap?"

Then negotiate how the grant is structured.

Acceleration. Carta's vesting guide describes two kinds. Single-trigger acceleration vests unvested equity on an acquisition alone. Double-trigger requires an acquisition and your being terminated without cause, and Carta says it's the more common of the two because buyers want people to stay after the deal. Asking for double-trigger is a reasonable request at most startups.

Early exercise. Some startups let you exercise before vesting. Paired with an 83(b) election, which IRS Publication 525 says must be filed within 30 days after the property is transferred, it can move future gains toward capital-gains treatment. You're paying for shares you could forfeit, so it suits people who are confident they'll stay.

A shorter cliff. The cliff is the part of the schedule that costs you most if the job doesn't work out, and it's a narrower ask than more shares. "Given the unvested equity I'm leaving behind, could we shorten the cliff to six months?" gives the company one specific thing to say yes to.

A longer exercise window. Ask how long you have to exercise vested options after you leave. A short window can force a large cash decision at the worst moment.

A competing offer. If you have one with stronger equity, say so without reciting numbers. "I have another offer with a stronger equity package" is enough to give the company a reason to move.

How do senior hires negotiate equity alongside base salary?

At senior levels equity can be a large share of the package, so negotiate it as its own item. Ask about refresh grants directly. Some companies give additional equity once the initial grant starts running down, practice varies, and a vague "we're competitive on refreshers" isn't a policy.

Get the answer to three things in writing before you accept. What the refresh policy is, how performance affects it, and whether the vesting schedule on refreshers matches the initial grant. A new-hire grant that looks generous over four years can leave a cliff in year five if nothing replaces it.

Senior candidates can also ask for a sign-on equity top-up to cover unvested equity they're walking away from. Bring the vesting statement from your current employer, because it turns the request from a feeling into a number the company can check.

Should you exercise vested options?

Exercising is a cash decision, and in Carta's data most vested, in-the-money grants went unexercised. In the fourth quarter of 2024, employees at startups on Carta exercised just 32.2% of equity grants that were both fully vested and in the money, Carta's Kevin Dowd reported. "Exercising options is expensive," SignalFire partner Heather Doshay told Carta. "If you're a person who's not wealthy, which is most of us, you are going into your savings and having to make a serious decision about where you're investing your extra capital."

ISOs add a tax wrinkle. IRS Publication 525 says that for the alternative minimum tax, stock from an ISO exercise is treated as if no special treatment applied, so exercising can create an AMT bill even if you never sell. NSOs are taxed as ordinary income on the spread when you exercise.

A tax advisor who specializes in equity compensation earns the fee here. The rules are unforgiving, and the cost of advice is small next to the cost of a mistake on a large exercise.

What's overrated

Share counts. A big number of options can make an equity offer look better than it is, and it means nothing until you know the fully diluted total and the strike price. Ask for the percentage and the preferred price before you react to the count at all.

Your playbook this week

  1. Ask the recruiter for the 409A valuation, the fully diluted share count, the latest preferred price and the full vesting schedule.
  2. Work out your annual equity value and your total compensation, then compare both with market data for your level.
  3. Write a two-sentence counter that names one equity change and the market reason for it.
  4. Ask about refreshers, acceleration and the post-departure exercise window, and get the answers in writing.
  5. Rehearse the call out loud. In Four-Leaf's comp negotiation coach, you can enter the offer's equity per year beside the base, then practice scenarios like "That's the top of the band" before the real conversation.

The question to keep asking

If the equity turned out to be worth zero, would you still be happy with the base salary and the role? If yes, the equity is genuine upside. If no, you're taking a pay cut dressed up as a bet. That can still be the right call, as long as you make it with your eyes open.


Related reading:

Try it free

Ready to ace your next interview?

Practice with AI-powered mock interviews, tailor your resume, and negotiate your salary, all in one platform.

3-day trial. No credit card required.